She didn’t take the job…but it’s not her it’s you

I spend a lot of time banging on about the ridiculous things that jobseekers do to undermine their search for a new position, but every now and then I hear of a hiring manager who says something so BLATANTLY ridiculous, that you have no choice but to apologise to the candidate who has taken time out of their busy day to meet with them. Read on and weep (with laughter)… Let me set the scene dear reader…there is one section of the job market where good candidates make hen’s teeth look as common as muck. Employers literally fight like real ‘Housewives of Melbourne’ to get these good candidates on board.

It’s beyond competitive, it’s insane. So here we have a most excellent candidate, let’s call her Bob.

I like that name because in my head it is Edmund Blackadder saying it (if you are too young for Edmund Blackadder I weep for you). Bob has the skills, the experience and the attitude to get multiple job offers in a week. She is, as they say, the whole package. Bob is meeting with a hiring manager. She is meeting the office manager for a role where she will be supporting one of the most senior managers in the business. It’s a great business too; high profile, sexy offices, lots of ongoing training and career development opportunities.

The stars align! Until…. During the interview, the office manager said something like this….. “So what star sign are you? The senior manager is [star sign] and it’s important that we know if you will be compatible.” WTF. Like literally. WTF. Since WHEN is star sign alignment a legitimate recruitment technique? What, are we one step away from getting tarot card readings to predict performance? The candidate called us after the interview and suggested that she would be better off considering other, more professional, options. Can’t blame her really. So let’s not blame candidates for every interview stuff up…sometimes it’s not them, it’s you.

Share this article

Useful links

Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us
Lisa Johnson • June 22, 2016

Recent insights

By Rachel Adams May 19, 2024
In today's dynamic work environment, flexibility is paramount. As the needs and expectations of the modern workforce continue to evolve, employers are increasingly adopting adaptable work arrangements to meet diverse needs and enhance productivity. In this blog post, we'll explore the significance of adaptable work arrangements and how they address the evolving demands of today's workforce while optimizing for search engine visibility.
By Hamish Lamberton May 12, 2024
In recent years, the rise of remote work has revolutionized the way companies approach recruitment. With advancements in technology and a growing acceptance of virtual communication tools, many organizations are now embracing remote recruitment strategies to attract and hire top talent. In this blog post, we'll explore how companies are adapting to virtual hiring processes and the strategies they're employing to succeed in this new era of recruitment.
By Esha Nischol May 8, 2024
In today's rapidly evolving landscape, automation is reshaping industries and transforming the way we work. While automation offers numerous benefits, including increased efficiency and productivity, it also presents challenges and uncertainties for the workforce. Understanding the opportunities and challenges of automation on employment is crucial for individuals and organizations alike as we navigate the future of work.

UK's 2024 Employment and Salary Trends Report

Salary trends, talent attraction and retention strategies

Have your say in the future of work
Share by: