What NOT to do when you're temping and want a pay raise

Lisa Johnson • June 16, 2021

You have just found out that someone is getting paid more than you, and you are incandescent with rage. You want an immediate review of your hourly pay rate. You're mad. You feel ripped off, and you want justice. Well, here is what NOT to do on your way to negotiating a temp pay increase.

What NOT To Do

Compare yourself to the person next to you
Stop talking about money with your colleagues. Quite frankly, it's none of their business what you get paid, and it's none of your business what they are paid. You have negotiated and accepted a pay rate to take the job, and they have done the same. There is a fine balance in pay rate negotiations – there is what the job is 'worth', there is what the client will pay, and there is what the casual employee will accept. Most times, the client’s budget dictates how much a temporary employee can be paid, but the power is not always with the client. There is nothing wrong with asking your consultant if there is room to move on the base pay rate – but do this at the time of accepting the assignment.

Call another agency when tired and emotional
This happened to us last week. A casual employee working with one of our clients through another agency found out that his base pay rate was less than our temporary employees. He called our consultant and demanded the right to be able to work through us. The short answer is: we can't do anything about this. The other agency introduced the casual employee to the client, and the employment relationship is clearly with them. We have no rights to or responsibilities for casual employees working through a different agency. The only thing our consultant could do was tell the temp to call his agency and talk to them about a pay increase....calmly.

Complain about the money your agency makes from you
Ahh, my favorite. I will be brutally honest; we are not a charitable organization. We charge a margin (our revenue) in addition to the candidate's pay rate, because we are in business. Hopefully, we actually make a profit! Agency margins are being squeezed all the time. There are some industries where a high margin is still standard operating practice, but we operate in a free market environment, and with competition that is happy to 'give away the farm', so to speak, we don't actually make as much profit from you as you may think. For a start, you can't look at the difference between what you are being paid and what we are charging the client and think of that as profit. That difference includes all of your on costs (super, payroll tax, workers comp insurances and so on), and then there is the cost of doing business, consultant salary, advertising, administration, systems, rent, equipment…the list is endless, believe me. There are recruitment businesses struggling and, unfortunately, entering administration in Australia all the time. You might think it's 'money for jam', but it's an expensive business to run. Sales can be high, but the profit negligible. The impact on cash flow is significant.

 So what should you do if you want your pay rate reviewed?
Here are my tips on negotiating a pay increase:
  • Before calling your consultant, review the job you have been doing. Are you doing more than what you were originally employed to do? If so, this is an excellent place to start from when negotiating a pay increase.

  • Understand what award you are covered by and what the minimum rate is for that award. Your agency is required by law to tell you what award you are working under (if applicable) and how your grade/level pay rate is calculated. If you are concerned you are being paid below award level, you can easily check this against the modern awards listing on the Fair Work Australia website. If you find that your pay rate is too low, call your agency and quote the award, grade and minimum rate – they should immediately review your pay rate as a result.

  • Be nice! It's not easy asking for a pay increase, and we are all emotionally involved in what we get paid, but approaching a pay rise with an aggressive manner will immediately put your consultant off. They will stop listening to what you say because they will be focusing on how you are saying it. Try to be calm and reasonable. Be polite and be prepared to wait for a definitive answer. A consultant will never agree to a pay increase off the bat; they need to take what you have told them, analyze the role and talk to the client before giving you a final answer.

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia
   I    United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.

Recent articles

By Liz Jones April 16, 2025
Over half of UK employees would consider quitting if they discovered their employer was monitoring them, according to recent research. With 85% of businesses admitting to tracking screen activity and website usage, employee trust is at risk. In this blog, people2people’s UK Managing Director Liz Jones explores the impact of surveillance on workplace culture, stress, and retention. Learn how to strike the right balance between oversight and autonomy, with practical strategies to build a trust-first culture that supports both performance and wellbeing. Is your business protecting productivity—or pushing your top talent away? Read more to find out.
By Liz Jones April 15, 2025
With the new financial year underway, UK businesses are reassessing hiring strategies and tax planning to maximise savings and ensure compliance. In this blog, people2people’s UK Managing Director Liz Jones speaks with Senior Consultant Maddy Laing about smarter workforce planning, contractor compliance, and aligning staffing with business goals. We also explore practical tax tips to avoid an EOFY hangover—covering recordkeeping, deductions, and super contributions. Learn how to get ahead with a proactive approach that reduces costs, avoids risk, and drives growth from day one. Are you setting your business up for a smarter, more strategic year ahead? Read more to find out.
A woman in a suit is giving a plaque to another woman
By Hannah Slee March 19, 2025
Employee recognition is no longer just a ‘nice to have’—it’s a strategic necessity. In the UK, 54% of organisations now prioritise regular appreciation, with recognised employees 8x more likely to feel a sense of belonging and 5x more likely to stay. Businesses with strong recognition cultures see 87% lower burnout rates, improving morale and retention. Simple, consistent praise—whether through team meetings, milestones, or digital platforms—can boost engagement. Are you doing enough to recognise your employees and keep them motivated? Read our latest blog to find out how to build a culture of appreciation.
A woman is sitting at a desk working on a computer.
By Hannah Slee March 17, 2025
In 2025, graphic design interviews are about more than creativity—employers want problem-solvers, strong communicators, and adaptable professionals. A standout portfolio should showcase process, not just final designs, with 4-6 high-quality projects. Candidates must be ready to explain their design decisions, handle client feedback, and demonstrate technical skills in Adobe Suite, AutoCAD, and Revit. Soft skills like communication and collaboration are just as vital as software proficiency. Want to know how to structure your portfolio and answer key interview questions to land your dream design job? Read our latest blog for expert insights and tips.
An application form with a pen on top of it
By Hannah Slee March 12, 2025
Job seekers are under increasing pressure to stand out, leading many to exaggerate their CVs. However, with AI-driven background checks, dishonesty can ruin career prospects. Instead of taking shortcuts, focus on tailoring your CV, highlighting skills, and leveraging networking to secure roles authentically. Employers value transparency, and a strategic approach to job searching will always outweigh the risks of deception. Want to know the best ways to strengthen your job application while staying honest? Read on to discover expert insights and actionable tips to help you land your next opportunity with integrity!

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us